Chinchilla Community Forums

General Chat => Other Pets => Topic started by: Hoppinchins on February 01, 2011, 10:39:01 AM

Title: harnest vs collor
Post by: Hoppinchins on February 01, 2011, 10:39:01 AM
Does anyone know if for small dogs its better to have a harnest instead of a collor for going on walks and suck?
Title: Re: harnest vs collor
Post by: chinclub on February 01, 2011, 02:10:41 PM
I think it depends on the dog.  My cockapoo walks very good on a leash so a collar is all he needs.  My bloodhound is horrible about pulling so we give him a harness.  It gives us better control and places the pressure against his wide chest area rather than his delicate throat.
Title: Re: harnest vs collor
Post by: jmdebb on February 01, 2011, 03:47:07 PM
i never owned small dogs, but i have to agree with jamie.. 
Title: Re: harnest vs collor
Post by: Hoppinchins on February 01, 2011, 06:14:45 PM
I might try a harness and see if that works better. She is usually pretty good with the collar, but she may like the harness better. I haven't been able to take her on many walks yet.
Title: Re: harnest vs collor
Post by: Debbie.nl.ca on February 02, 2011, 07:54:26 AM
I would love to have gotten Chance into a harness , but he wouldn't have it. ::)
They use slip chains in his obedience classes and he's doing very well with it, but I rather his collar. ::nod::
Remember you are head of the pack, not her  ;)
Title: Re: harnest vs collor
Post by: megoony99 on February 02, 2011, 09:14:35 AM
Depends on the dog.  I have a basenji that I couldn't walk on a harness.  He would just walk on his hind legs.  Then I tried a collar.  He pulled so hard that he would choke him self.  After that I used a gentle leader.  It works like a charm.  What it does is everytime he pulls it turn his head toward me.  Now my min pin I have to use a slip chain.  She can slide her self out of any harnass or collar. 
Title: Re: harnest vs collor
Post by: Jhenderson27 on February 02, 2011, 01:41:12 PM
Hey Debbie, tell my parents that about being the leader of the pack.  Our husky Stella rules their house. 
Title: Re: harnest vs collor
Post by: Hoppinchins on February 02, 2011, 03:38:45 PM
I know i am. I'm trying to leash train her, along with the other stuff, but don't think I really know how to do that.
Title: Re: harnest vs collor
Post by: Hoppinchins on February 02, 2011, 03:39:24 PM
She also doesn't always come when I call her while we are outside. Its like she is in her own world then.
Title: Re: harnest vs collor
Post by: jmdebb on February 02, 2011, 09:53:04 PM
never do a recall off lead until your dog knows it well, reason being [for any command] once they know they dont' have to listen, you are in trouble.  teach him everything with the lead on him, use treats to get him to want to do it.  like for instance, when i did come with bear.. actually okay i did it off lead, but like we would be at the park, and i would start to run, dog will follow, then yell COME.. and keep running [backwards so you can watch him coming] and eventually he will catch up and GOOD BOY> TREAT.  i dont' know if all dogs will follow if you run, i have shephards and they tend to want to be near you.. so it works like a charm. 

and as for the choke chain, YUP, they stink.. most people do not realize not to use them because they can certainly harm a dog because of what you said, they just keep pulling and pulling and choke themselves.. 

personally i have to use  a prong, and its more humane than a choke. i have never used a gentle leader, but i should probably try one.  i wonder if it would work on bear.. he's so darn strong tho.